Needing a help or advise to fix my 2009 Corolla

Hi all,

My 2009 Corolla was involved in the accident and I am afraid it has to be out of my pocket.
I was wondering whether I can just buy the parts from Ebay and repair it myself.
But the problem is I would not be able to paint them in the same color.

I got some quotation from a few body shops but the cheapeast was $1,300.
Do you think it is reasonable?

If I can find the same front bumper, left fender, and left hand lamp assembly in Magnetic gray in the junkyard, that would me wonderful.
I am currently located in the north side of Chicago region.

Thank you for any advise or help in advance.